Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

New wingtips...

9 posts in this topic

Posted

part1

my original Kitfox droop style tips were repaired already several times and therefore way too heavy. Further I like the look of the more modern ones. So it was very welcome to get a set borrowed by a buddy for creating a mold. Due to great stiffness to weight ratio I decided to use a honeycomb sandwich construction (for the first time).

The better the master form the better the mold the better the final produced part. So it was nice that I was allowed to repair, sand, paint and finally polish the samples.

Next step was to fix the quite flexible part safely for further handling onto a wooden board (by the way the borrowed parts belonged to a plane in service so any damage or drilling should be avoided)

IMG_6504.thumb.JPG.1c95982e279545cdef6e7IMG_6509.thumb.JPG.fb760c4012b6363d4f366

IMG_6519.thumb.JPG.4d3bd554941c695ef4d37IMG_6546.thumb.JPG.772c8b6944fddc23541a9

 

As a 2-piece mold was necessary it was kind of tricky to arrange a ´parting plane` where the mold later splits

IMG_6567.thumb.JPG.b113febeeaca481c90d5cIMG_6563.thumb.JPG.11be1c7314c0f069b2d7f

after some trimming the small left gap was sealed with modeling compound.

Cleaning/waxing - ready to cast the top half!

 IMG_6582kl.thumb.jpg.84d514b001128edd536IMG_6585.thumb.JPG.7df22ef699cdc33d63dce

to be continued...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Very nice!  I just walked into my drooped tip yesterday (for the I don't know how many time).  The new style do look better.  JImChuk

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Part2

See how the black resin molding compound faded more and more as the fiberglass layup builds. I decided to make a strong mold which also can handle tempering. Maybe overkill, but I need to make at least 2 sets

IMG_6653.thumb.JPG.5ddae88384861e09f5fa7IMG_6655.thumb.JPG.5336931e3523d47fd2bc5IMG_6656.thumb.JPG.cb154fc462205c19625f7

Exciting moment. Will the top half release? Original part unscathed? As with 2-piece molds it is better not to demold until finish both halves, I could not withstand to ckeck. If something would have gone wrong only one surface would be damaged…

IMG_6591.thumb.JPG.93d23e9a9ee7fcc04facb

As everything turned out as expected, I continued. Lower half (removed parting) and certainly opposite wingtip.

IMG_6629.thumb.JPG.c0460388339d212fa8d31IMG_6630.thumb.JPG.dff9f1bd84bb7837904e7

Almost ready. Some trimming and bolts to secure alignment added. No need for ground board anymore...

IMG_6666.thumb.JPG.de80d3c43b024798439a5IMG_6670.thumb.JPG.718c81bfc35ccc1392938

Finished mold righthand, white is original wingtip (still with insert)

stains are residues of release agent, I forgot to remove before photoshoot

IMG_6679.thumb.JPG.ce3e86ff682f8105eba12

 

Next. Let`s make parts…

To be continued…

7 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted


Nice job!! That's real talent to be able to do work with fiber glass like you just did.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Part3

So after cleaning the molds were polished and coated carefully several times using release agent. Finally first parts were made. I decided to go with a sandwich construction consisting of only 3 very thin layers of fiberglass enclosing an aramide honeycomb core. Each wingtip is made up of two halves which were glued together later using a reinforcement tape.

 Some may ask why no carbon fiber?

I wanted to have both lightweight but also robust wingtips. To achieve this with pure carbon layup, more layers soaking lots of resin (=weight) would be needed. Pricy and IMHO no advantage here.

 Further, I wanted to try a sandwich construction using vacuum technique anyway in view of future components like cowling, seatpan, etc., I`m planning to do.

 

IMG_6856.thumb.JPG.c1189254e01e0a85ed628

All four waxed molds have gelcoat and first layer of 80gram on - let it set.

 If proceed w/o wait following vacuum pressing would cause imprint on top surface…

 

 

IMG_6888.thumb.JPG.322284f856a15cc1ac168

Next is matching/cutting the honeycomb core. Nice material easy to work with, though expensive. The uncovered area will later touch the aluminum stripe attached to the outer rib.

 

IMG_6984.thumb.JPG.8f07733b45de0bfe1533c

Honeycomb is glued in a wet bed of an underneath additional 80gram layer. Covered by perforated film (blue) absorber fleece (white) and a peel ply stripe. Afterwards the package was carefully put into a poly bag. A vacuum pump will soak excess resin through the foil into the absorber. Less resin means less weight!

 

IMG_6907.thumb.JPG.b6403543db2718ee4b89a

Pump is working at least until resin has set (better 5h). Check for leaks!

Time for beer or coffee!

 

To be continued…

6 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

Part4

vacuum process was successful! :)

honeycomb bonds perfect w/o bubbles or unglued spots. Next was some grinding to get a nice fit and smooth transitions...

IMG_6916.thumb.JPG.9e992bbf5f213a27b11ac

 

...test fitting the molds together to check fot both clearance an space for glue. The honeycomb offers a nice surface for a strong bond.

IMG_6915.thumb.JPG.37541b30679f33a313c1b

Then again into the vacuum bag after the inner top layer was applied. coffeetime!:BC:

IMG_6989.thumb.JPG.f41236bfd6619b4c4c9e8

 

Now the sandwich is ready, including both inner and outer layers enclosing the honeycomb. Cutting protrusions and preparing for bonding. 

IMG_6918.thumb.JPG.34a47f42aaa4bc2332403

 

Finally the halves were glued together using additional 1" reinforcing tape covering seam and edges. Now it`s getting hot! Both wingtips, still in their molds went into a heated box for tempering the epoxy resin for about 8 hours @ 75 deg. C.

IMG_6923.thumb.JPG.cff8f688bb4e2cf62f712l

 

Exciting moment. Final demolding! No trouble, no damage! YES!!!  

IMG_6955.thumb.JPG.ffb555503b72d429518c4

 

Even slightly better than calculated. Final part is 730grams means 1.6lbs?! Further only 40grams variation between left and right part. That is marginal for homemade handcrafted production ::)

IMG_6954.thumb.JPG.ddad32cf1621e416c4378

 

 

Finished part, ready for paint preparation

IMG_6956.thumb.JPG.fb4a315c6b21be2edd605

End of story 

Edited by motortommy
3 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

So was it worth the effort? Yes and No!

For the spent money (materials, tools, …) I could have bought likely a set of factory tips, including horrific transatlantic shipping cost. Further it took me roughly 3 months (sure not fulltime) from scratch to finished part, but:

-        my wingtips were in desolate condition, badly repaired and way too heavy (left 2.3kgs/right 2.7kgs)

-        even the modern style tips I borrowed still weighed 1.5/1.7kgs

-        my new parts weigh 1.5 per set, means only by replacing the tips I saved 3.5kgs including preferred new look for free!  

-        I wanted to try, if I´m still able and willing to work with fiberglass (after having 25years break) as my planning is to touch seatpan, cowling, wingtanks, panel,… as well

Finally after tearing the whole plane down for months finding more and more issues I didn`t like, it was mentally important to create something gaining strength to proceed with the project. These wingtips were the first new homemade parts I made for my plane…

OMG it´s difficult to express…hope you get my point.

Thanks for reading!

6 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Thanks for sharing. You have every right to feel a sense of satisfaction and brag about making those wingtips! They are a work of art, very nicely done. 

:BC:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Superb job Tommy,

If you decide to make any more you could sell them on and recover some of your costs ;) (I'm based n the UK)

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0